Are my expectation too high?

xbackgolden

New Member
We all must remember one thing. LFS take all the risk when they purchase fish from any Aro farm. There are neither consignments done nor guarantees to the LFS when he makes an order to have a selection in his store from an Aro farm.
Each farm has a high minimum number purchase, and by the time a LFS gets his delivery, be it 15 to 35 AroÂ’s, they are in the hole for thousands of dollars. That is not including operating costs, electricity, medication, etc.
We as buyers go to the LFS when we hear about the deliveries arriving within the GTA. Some stores even open doors at midnight for their preferred customers.

We have all seen AroÂ’s come in from their long journey here and when we see them, we are not overly impressed at their appearance because they are not in great shape.
LFS now have to make them look good so that they can sell as many or get deposits on the AroÂ’s to at least recoup some of his investment as soon as the stock arrive. Time is of the essence at this pint and the "Buyer Rush" will only last a few days.
We have all seen LFS holding on to old stock for a few months sometimes over a year before they sell the one's that did not get picked.
I guess you can say that this is why I feel for them at times. In reality they were the one's that took the risk in the late 80's and early 90's to get the fish here and got most of us started. I am a veteran in Arowana keeping since the late 80’s. I was first smitten when I seen my first fully developed RTG. Believe it or not it was at BIG Al’s in the west end. I said to myself, “I must have one of those. I’m sure you all have had similar experiences.

I am not a store owner nor do I have a vested interest in any of the stores in the GTA as some people may think.
My options are open and what interests me is QUALITY and I'm not counting on luck to get what I want.
My personal goal is just like some other members in this Forum, and that is to get the highest quality Arowana available for my collection here in CAN.
Of course I will pay less if I can, I would be a fool and a liar if I told you I wouldn't. But as far as what I have seen over the years, we, in Canada are not getting what the rest of SE Asia is getting.

Some PPL may feel ripped off by LFS when it comes to Aro's, but we still have to rely on them for supplies like filters, aquariums, and other supplies we use day to day in our hobby.
As for group buys, yes, it is a growing trend in the purchase of Aro's, but the stigma attached still holds me back from ordering. It is the "luck of the draw" process.
Not knowing what I will be getting until they hand me the bag, that‘s my issue.
I'm sure; as group buying evolves it may become the norm in buying Aro's.
I know that there is talk about a visual, video and pics of fish before you buy your next group buy Arowana. I may at that point switch to group buys.
But the majority of you must agree with me that there is no comparison to seeing that Arowana live. Seeing the graceful swimming action that it performs, and how it reacts to you as you stare at it for hours at the LFS.
This same topic is going on in SE Asia as we speak. Their dilemma is weather they should purchase from their LFS or group purchase from Indo. The main debate is it’s a “BLIND BUY”.

As for those looking for the lowest price, yes you may get your Aro, but will you get a high quality, maybe not. There is always someone out there willing to pay the price when it comes to quality. Yes, you will sit there staring at that empty aquarium scratching your head and saying to your self, "Who paid that price for that fish?"

Here's the Aro farmers point of view.
Canada has buyers willing to purchase a group of AroÂ’s , but we have price issues. We want to pay what Singapore pays for their AroÂ’s.
Japan, China, Korea, and other SE Asian countries will pay thousand more for an excellent specimen without batting an eye. If you are the Aro farmer who will you call on first, Canada or Japan?
The dividing line is now between buyers of Arowana's and Arowana Connoisseurs. There has to be a supply in the market for all qualities of ArowanaÂ’s. There is LOW, MEDIUM, & of course HIGH. A store canÂ’t keep too many of the other. LFS has to strategically decide what they will carry to be competitive.

To sum things up, in a real world, you will never be able to buy a brand new fully loaded BMW M5 @ a brand new fully loaded HONDA Accord price. I donÂ’t care how long you wait.
That is the same with ArowanaÂ’s.
Decide what type you want to keep and how much you are willing to pay. As long as there is a JAPANESE & SE Asia market for ArowanaÂ’s we will never see a low priced flawless example here. We here in CAN cannot really compete with the YEN pocket book unless you have a lot of $$$ and ready to spend it. IÂ’m not saying itÂ’s impossible, but it will cost you more than the $900 or $1200, your willing to pay.
There are a lot of guyÂ’s here in the GTA with deep pockets seeking that flawless specimen be it RED or GOLD at this moment and you all know who you are.
Once you have a few of those around looking to buy, they will bid for it and that Arowana will sell to the highest bidder.

What do I consider Flawless you ask?
I will ask you this; have you ever seen a real Red Aro? One that is not orange, or deep orange in colour, but RED!!! No enhancements, like red lights or computer enhanced or photo shopped.
Pure RED features in natural un-adulterated white light, LIVE or on line. Perfect body shape what ever your preference, Scale sheen and scale formations etc. Then ask yourself; “How many are there here in CAN, and how many did you go through in your search to find one.” Maybe it’s already the show piece in your home aquarium?

Which one R U? :)


To add on to what you have said. It is popular misconception that once the parent fish are of premium quality, (I own a pond of premium quality brooders back at home) All the fry will turn out to be of similar quality as their parents. From my experience of keeping fishes and of buying the entire brood from the individual parent's harvest, I have found that this is quite far from the truth. Generally, only about 20-30% of the fishes will be of premium quality, after that, the rest of them will be of relatively ok quality while there will be a remainder which is of substandard quality, (xbacks with no pearlies etc, red aros which grow up to be orange)

What i am trying to say essentially is that there are not really that many good arowanas around in the market. Most of is often spotted and taken by export customers of our local farms, friends of the farmers and the LFS. Hence for the price you are willing to pay, it is qutie unlikely that any of these are available to you. Also, the farms want to ensure the continuality of their business as they won't be willing to upset their best customers by sending them substandard fish.

With regard to grading of the super red, I won't comment too much as I am not really a specialist in super reds. But, not grading means that you might get a chance of getting a better quality specimen, but it can also mean you will get a substandard speciment too. So essentially the end user is bearing the risk. So its really up to you to decide what you want. For me, the fish already cost me thousands of dollars, why not pay that 10-20% more to ensure that the quality meets my expectations.
 

Cirrus

Arowana blogger
What i am trying to say essentially is that there are not really that many good arowanas around in the market. Most of is often spotted and taken by export customers of our local farms, friends of the farmers and the LFS. Hence for the price you are willing to pay, it is qutie unlikely that any of these are available to you. Also, the farms want to ensure the continuality of their business as they won't be willing to upset their best customers by sending them substandard fish.

The situation you describe above is what Dragonfish.ca now has going with Panda Aquatics. We have become a stable and repeat customer (7 orders and growing), and so Mr.Kan provides us the best fish he can. I should mention again we are paying a premium for this service. I have got quotes from many other farms in Singapore. I can tell you that I can source cheaper fish elsewhere for sure. But I don't because I trust the quality that Mr.Kan provides us.

We have a shipment of mostly very high end aros arriving in Vancouver today! We'll try to post photos as soon as possible.
 

Cirrus

Arowana blogger
Acutally Panda, does not export that much now days.

But what they do export is of very good quality! :)
I monitor the posts on Arofanatics, etc., and there have been more than one lately by local guys in S'pore saying that some really good stock at Panda was marked as "sold for export", and that the fish were headed for...Canada! Needless to say, I smile when I read such posts! :)

In fact, I feel that a smaller exporter provides better value! Were I dealing with Quian Hu etc., I doubt I'd be dealing direct with the president of the company nor having him choose the fish directly for me.

As it is now, I have Mr.Kan's home phone number and have struck up a friendship as well as business relationship. I feel very fortunate in this and am sure everyone who buys a Panda fish through Dragonfish also benefits! :)
 

protoxeno

New Member
Well said Theo.

Just because the LFS are the ones that first to import and introduce dragonfish to the Canadian market that doesn't give them the right to lie and deceit in order to make a sale and should give the mentality of us as pure passion hobbyist to hold back and just let their monopoly run. If theres something bad about a LFS, shouldn't we as hobbyist share that knowledge instead of going through "Hey I respect the LFS since they are the one to introduce dragonfish to Canada."

And the minimum 15 fishes and 30 fishes that LFS buy from farms, well let me tell you in the GTA they dont' buy direct from farms, they buy together to make up those 15 or 30 fishes from AGENTS who put together their order. Now agents are not affiliated with farms, they just put together orders and sends them and I think its intuitive to think agents over SEasia dont' really ship under such heavy minimum requirements like 15 to 30 fishes. Now those 15 or 30 fishes that LFS take is divided among how many LFS that exists in the GTA so really how much risk are they taking when the entire order is divided up as such?

Ok you may say that "Hey LFS don't actually carry like 2-4 fishes, but MORE than 7 fishes on some bigger dragonfish stores in the GTA, so they take a big risk if it was that many right? You know who they are." If that is true so when they actually combine their order that would mean a HUGE number of fishes right? That only means that each individual fish itself is just cost way less. Common sense that the more you buy, the bigger the savings. Nevertheless, just because someone is taking a big risk in doing business doesn't make any sense whatsoever to have customers give pity and go shop there even though they are the only ones that have a product at an extremely high price. Individuals will come up with a way to buy it cheaper from else where because this is a free market and not some monopoly, unless your Debeers. No group orders to buy diamonds from mines in Africa.
 

protoxeno

New Member
With regard to grading of the super red, I won't comment too much as I am not really a specialist in super reds. But, not grading means that you might get a chance of getting a better quality specimen, but it can also mean you will get a substandard speciment too. So essentially the end user is bearing the risk. So its really up to you to decide what you want. For me, the fish already cost me thousands of dollars, why not pay that 10-20% more to ensure that the quality meets my expectations.

Yes I agree I would pay 10-20% more, but in Canada LFS charge isn't the price your used to seeing, its more like 100% more.
 

EKen

Super Moderator
So I guess basically two schools of philosophy on the subject. And I can also notice that the forum became mainly a debate dojo on who are right. I think we are getting far away from the main objective of this place...

Maybe the main "debaters" should tell each others their point of view via PMs.
 

Cirrus

Arowana blogger
So I guess basically two schools of philosophy on the subject. And I can also notice that the forum became mainly a debate dojo on who are right. I think we are getting far away from the main objective of this place...

Maybe the main "debaters" should tell each others their point of view via PMs.

I agree with your first paragraph, but not with your second.

If I saw this thread being repeated elsewhere in different words, I think that would be wrong and unhealthy for the forum. As it is, I think this thread should maybe be retitled, "Group buy versus LFS buy"? Provided we are respectful of one another, do not insult, and do not use deceit or dirty tactics, I think it is healthy for Arowana-heads such as ourselves to have such a debate. And lets face it, it is a DEBATE! :D

And like most debates, there is no clear winner or loser to be had. There are two competing philosophies or points of view. Each has its strengths and weakneses.

In some ways this could turn into a "never ending thread" in that it is the kind of subject that lends itself to reinterpretation over and over and over!

So, let's keep the topic contained to this thread, be respectful of one another, and try to learn together.

And there is a LOT to learn I think. For example, I am learning just how different the Asian arowana market is in Eastern Canada from Western Canada. Wow what a difference! In Western Canada we have three main stores that control the market - Big Als, King Ed Pets, and a shop in Alberta I believe (Albertans help out here!). This compares with what looks like many many shops out East! This is fascinating stuff to learn fI think... :)
 

xbackgolden

New Member
But what they do export is of very good quality! :)
I monitor the posts on Arofanatics, etc., and there have been more than one lately by local guys in S'pore saying that some really good stock at Panda was marked as "sold for export", and that the fish were headed for...Canada! Needless to say, I smile when I read such posts! :)

In fact, I feel that a smaller exporter provides better value! Were I dealing with Quian Hu etc., I doubt I'd be dealing direct with the president of the company nor having him choose the fish directly for me.

As it is now, I have Mr.Kan's home phone number and have struck up a friendship as well as business relationship. I feel very fortunate in this and am sure everyone who buys a Panda fish through Dragonfish also benefits! :)

I wouldn't agree with this statement, The President of the arowana department is Mr Yap Kim Chun. If you call Wan Hu, the arowana division of Qian Hu, you will speak to him directly. As for choosing the fish, you can request he choose the fish for you. In fact, Qian hu supplies arowana to many of the local arowana farms who run out of supply. Remember arowana are a seasonal breeding fish that do not breed in great quantity. So, it does not necessaryily mean that if you have customers means you have fish to sell and vice versa. Its the same with Qian Hu or any other arowana farm panda included.
 

protoxeno

New Member
I might not know much aobut the Canadian market, but how much is a decent red sold at an LFS?

A decent red? All the red I see in LFS so far is pretty pale and silverly and they didn't just receive the shipments, I wait after a month or so after the shipment comes in for the colours like you said to come back and the fish recover from stress when first landed. And those all cost from 2000 to 2500 Canadian dollars which is about 3k+ in SGD. And their sizes are 10" or more for those that came in for about a few months. At that price I expect FR quality, red scales, red face at 6 inch.
 
Last edited:

xbackgolden

New Member
A decent red? All the red I see in LFS so far is pretty pale and silverly and they didn't just receive the shipments, I wait after a month or so after the shipment comes in for the colours like you said to come back and the fish recover from stress when first landed. And those all cost from 2000 to 2500 Canadian dollars which is about 3k+ in SGD. And their sizes are 10" or more for those that came in for about a few months. At that price I expect FR quality, red scales, red face at 6 inch.

that won't be possible, those pictures are doctored, or they are shot with nan light shining. It is very difficult to get red scales at 6 inches. almost impossible, I won't cite names, but i have access to the best reds in Singapore, they only start to show development at about 7 to 8 inches. It is really about the skill of the groomer and there are not many of these sort of people around. Considering even the LFS in Singapore, I don't think there are many people who are able to groom reds. Hence, that is the reason why they look silvery. However, if you do buy those mid size reds with color development, I am very confidient that you should be able to see a good amount of color.
 

xbackgolden

New Member
A decent red? All the red I see in LFS so far is pretty pale and silverly and they didn't just receive the shipments, I wait after a month or so after the shipment comes in for the colours like you said to come back and the fish recover from stress when first landed. And those all cost from 2000 to 2500 Canadian dollars which is about 3k+ in SGD. And their sizes are 10" or more for those that came in for about a few months. At that price I expect FR quality, red scales, red face at 6 inch.

That is the price that we are paying in Singapore also for a good Red of about 10 inches. Although small reds are cheap, those which develop good color will start to see the prices rising. I mean, even in Sg we sell mid size reds at about 2.5k SGD. And you can't really blame your importers because the farms sell in USD.
 

protoxeno

New Member
I actually got the quote from FR farm which we all know what farm provides FR right?, thats their FR price they offer me and said its 6inch with red cheeks and red scales. I am not refering to the pic I referenced but from the FR farm. Thats the thing, you get a good red for about the same price.

I don't think we get the same price at all because its 3k+ SGD and isn't Elegant Aqua selling a 22" VFSR thats for 2800 negotiable too? Thats not a 10" SR with potential aspect.

http://arofanatics.com/members/alvinheng/forsale22vfsr/
 
Last edited:

noaro

New Member
if u want to see a decent red go to gold ocean i saw their new shipment and was impressed. many are already sold.
 

Cirrus

Arowana blogger
I wouldn't agree with this statement, The President of the arowana department is Mr Yap Kim Chun. If you call Wan Hu, the arowana division of Qian Hu, you will speak to him directly. As for choosing the fish, you can request he choose the fish for you. In fact, Qian hu supplies arowana to many of the local arowana farms who run out of supply. Remember arowana are a seasonal breeding fish that do not breed in great quantity. So, it does not necessaryily mean that if you have customers means you have fish to sell and vice versa. Its the same with Qian Hu or any other arowana farm panda included.

As someone who lives in Singapore who is involved in the arowana business, you are at an advantage when it comes to dealing with such companies. I can assure you that as an outsider living in Canada, if you send them an email, it is not answered by the president of the company (at least it wasn't when I emailed). When you email Panda Aquatics you get a reply direct from Mr.Kan.

As for the quality of this firm's fish, I have a friend who recently bought 50 fish from them as a first time overseas customer and there were serious problems with 4 of them (basically unsaleable). Needless to say that first hand knowledge of mine makes me nervous to work with this firm in the future.
 

Cirrus

Arowana blogger
That is the price that we are paying in Singapore also for a good Red of about 10 inches. Although small reds are cheap, those which develop good color will start to see the prices rising. I mean, even in Sg we sell mid size reds at about 2.5k SGD. And you can't really blame your importers because the farms sell in USD.

In Vancouver a basic Super Red of about 5-6 inches, with no special colouration nor blush, has an asking price of $2500 Can. This works out to over $3500 Sing

http://finance.yahoo.com/currency/convert?amt=2500&from=CAD&to=SGD&submit=Convert

I believe that for $3500 Sing you would get more than a basic small SR?

If we jump up a level to mid size SR's with confirmed colouration, the price goes WAY WAY up...

I look forward to seeing the prices myself in S'pore next month. From what I know now I'd guess retail prices are about 50% of Canada's.
 

rulaifu

New Member
Let me say something. I played around in most of my posts trying to keep the site in a very humorous and entertaining one. Seems that it is time for me to say something now. And I will say this is the fair judgement based on my experience on having aros.
Let me take one spoon of rice with meal first. en, that it is.
When we talk about paying less for an aro. there is nothing wrong with that. but if you turn the attitude into NO LFS, but group buy, then it is wrong. In the market, we have so many different demands. And people have different tastes, which does exist everywhere and it is beyong the control. This is the economy. If you studied the book concerning MARSNO (Definitely wrong spelling because I only studied in Chinese, it is cleared stipulated for the 5 different demands)
For aros, some are willing to pay higher because they only focus on the top end quality. In general, people here is willing to spend 1000 ~ 1500 price for a red, so called decent quality.
Everyone here in Canada is well aware of one price, one service; and one price, one quality.
If Cirrus can prove that his aros. at the lower price can beat my aros., I will spend USD 20,000 to take 20 or 13 pieces more from him immediatley. Don't get me wrong that I want to pay higher price if I can get lower. But the thing is we are talking about quality issue at the same time.
Fairly speaking, you get what you paid, it is quite simple. (special cases are not involved because there is special case everywhere), I mean in general. So beating LFS for goupe buying does not sound good and fair. That is why I bring my comments here -- I mean serious this time.
If some LFS over priced their aros, then you can always walk away to find better deal from different LFS. So please don't attack LFS because of their higher price. In case someday you are the owner of LFS, your attitude will be totally different.
Again. One price, one service; one price, one quality.
 
Last edited:

rulaifu

New Member
if u want to see a decent red go to gold ocean i saw their new shipment and was impressed. many are already sold.

Not only gold ocean has decent red, but also some other LFS. I suggest we should be fair for all LFS.

We don't beat LFS by raising goupe buy, and we don't beat groupe buy by raising LFS. They should both exist to meet different demands level.

And in the meantime we don't beat LFS by raising one LFS. And we don't beat that LFS by raising others.

Wow, too serious. I hope I can go back to normal. More entertainment than being serious.
 

Cirrus

Arowana blogger
Not only gold ocean has decent red, but also some other LFS. I suggest we should be fair for all LFS.

We don't beat LFS by raising goupe buy, and we don't beat groupe buy by raising LFS. They should both exist to meet different demands level.

And in the meantime we don't beat LFS by raising one LFS. And we don't beat that LFS by raising others.

Wow, too serious. I hope I can go back to normal. More entertainment than being serious.

I agree with you here. But the exchange of ideas is good I think. People need to air their opinions and exchange them too, without fear of being attacked. So far so good! :)
 

Alx

New Member
To be honest I am somewhat confused with all this world pricing on Arowana, on one Business trip to London I've seen adult Fish purchased from Hong-Kong for British Corp Office in London at P23,000.00 that's over $40,000.00 CAN. In Ukraine (Kiev) and Russia (Moscow), I've seen them from $100 to $600US - for nice (from my opinion Reds and golds). And in Canada best looking fish I've seen in the LFS was at Riverfront Calgary for $5000.00

Conclusion, as I breed Discus and sell Discus, there are fish that I would sell and give discount, and there are my favorites (adult fish) that I am only willing to sell but at very high price ($400 and up). If someone don't like it - to bad, my fish, my choice. If I don't sell it - so much better, as they make good display and breeding samples. If people can get them somewhere else for cheaper, makes it easier for me - not to look for replacements or grow-out new from young once. Supply and demand is in control of the market.
 
Top